He Left Wall Street to Roast Coffee in the Rocky Mountains. Here's Why Thousands of Catholics Can't Get Enough.
What happens when a stockbroker trades his suit for a monk's habit—and his Bloomberg terminal for a coffee roaster?
Meet Mystic Monk Coffee—a Carmelite monastery in the rugged mountains of Clark, Wyoming, where monks wake before dawn to pray, chant the Divine Office, and roast some of the most beloved coffee in Catholic America. Founded by Father Daniel Mary, a former Wall Street stockbroker who left the trading floor to pursue a radical calling, Mystic Monk Coffee has become one of the most recognized Catholic businesses in the country. Every bag sold supports the monks' contemplative life and their ambitious dream of building a grand Gothic monastery in the Wyoming wilderness.
From Wall Street to the Wilderness
The story of Mystic Monk Coffee begins with a conversion so dramatic it reads like a novel.
Father Daniel Mary was once immersed in the high-pressure world of New York finance. He knew the rhythms of the trading floor—the opening bell, the ticker tape, the relentless chase for the next deal. But something was missing. The markets offered volatility, not peace. Profits, not purpose.
When the call to religious life became undeniable, he didn't just leave his career—he left the entire world behind.
He entered the Carmelite order, eventually founding a small community of monks in the mountains of northern Wyoming. The landscape is as austere as their vocation: snow-covered peaks, vast open ranges, and a silence so deep you can hear your own heartbeat.
It was here, in one of the most remote corners of the American West, that the monks began roasting coffee.
A Day in the Life of a Monk-Roaster
The monks of Wyoming follow the ancient Carmelite Rule. Their day begins in the dark, long before the sun crests the Rockies.
- 3:00 AM — The monks rise for Matins, the first prayer of the day
- Throughout the morning — Lauds, Mass, and hours of silent prayer
- Midday — Work begins, including the roasting operation
- Afternoon and evening — Vespers, Compline, and the Great Silence
Coffee roasting is woven into this rhythm. It is not a separate commercial enterprise bolted onto the side of a monastery. It is the monastery's work—their labora in the Benedictine tradition of ora et labora, pray and work.
When you brew a cup of Mystic Monk, you're participating in that ancient rhythm.
More Than a Cup of Coffee
What started as a modest operation to support the monastery has grown into a nationally known brand.
Mystic Monk Coffee offers a wide range of roasts—from their signature Cowboy Blend to seasonal favorites and flavored varieties like Royal Rum Pecan and Mystic Monk Blend. They roast in small batches at their monastery, and every order ships directly from the monks' hands to your doorstep.
But the coffee is only part of the story.
Each bag represents something the modern economy rarely offers: a product made with prayer. There are no marketing departments, no growth hackers, no venture capital pitch decks. Just monks, beans, a roaster, and the Rocky Mountains.
Building a Monastery, One Bag at a Time
The monks have a vision that stretches far beyond coffee.
Revenue from Mystic Monk Coffee supports their daily needs, but it also funds an extraordinary long-term project: the construction of a new Gothic monastery on their Wyoming property. The plans include a grand church, cloisters, a chapter house, and space for a growing community of monks.
Think about that for a moment. In an age of disposable startups and quarterly earnings reports, a group of men in habits are building something meant to last for centuries.
In an age when religious vocations are declining in many places, the Carmelite monks of Wyoming are thriving. Young men continue to join the community, drawn by the radical simplicity and deep prayer life. The monastery represents not just a building project but a statement of faith—that the contemplative life still matters, and that Catholic communities are willing to support it.
What Makes Mystic Monk Unique
There are thousands of coffee companies in America. Only one is run by cloistered monks in the Rocky Mountains. The combination is genuinely singular:
- Authenticity: This isn't a marketing gimmick. These are real monks living a real Rule of Life, roasting real coffee between hours of prayer.
- Quality: Small-batch roasting means freshness and attention to detail that mass-market brands can't match.
- Mission: Every dollar goes to supporting a monastic community and building a place of worship. There are no shareholders, no executive bonuses, no venture capital.
- Community: Mystic Monk has built a loyal following of Catholics (and coffee lovers of all stripes) who feel a genuine connection to the monks and their mission.
- Transparency: The monks are clear about where the money goes—to sustaining their life of prayer and building their monastery.
Why This Matters
Mystic Monk Coffee is one of the only businesses in America where your purchase directly sustains a community of cloistered monks dedicated to praying for the world. Without it, the Carmelite monks of Wyoming would lose their primary means of self-support — and their ambitious plan to build a Gothic monastery meant to stand for centuries would stall. In an economy dominated by venture-backed brands optimizing for shareholder returns, Mystic Monk is the rare enterprise where every dollar funds prayer, craftsmanship, and a vision that stretches far beyond the next quarterly report.
How You Can Support
- Order coffee at mysticmonkcoffee.com — try the Cowboy Blend or the Royal Rum Pecan for something special
- Set up a subscription so the monks can count on regular support (and you never run out of coffee)
- Give it as a gift — Mystic Monk makes a perfect Christmas, Easter, or ordination gift for the Catholic in your life
- Follow their journey and share their story on social media
- Pray for the monks and their growing community in Wyoming
Discover More Catholic Coffee & Monastic Goods — Go Paid
Mystic Monk is the most famous, but it is far from the only Catholic monastery or religious community selling handcrafted goods. Paid subscribers get our complete guide to monastic coffee roasters, abbey breweries, convent bakeries, and other religious enterprises across the U.S.
Paid subscribers get: curated Catholic business guides, exclusive deals from listed businesses, deep-dive interviews, and full directory access. Upgrade your subscription →
Have you tried Mystic Monk Coffee? What's your favorite roast? Drop a comment below and let us know how monastic coffee has become part of your morning routine.
Mystic Monk Coffee
- Website: mysticmonkcoffee.com
- Location: Clark, Wyoming
- Category: Coffee / Monastic Goods
- Instagram: @mysticmonkcoffee
- DCB Listing: Find Mystic Monk Coffee on Discover Catholic Business
Sources: Mystic Monk Coffee, Carmelite Monks of Wyoming, Discover Catholic Business