Finding the right real estate agent is one of the most consequential decisions a homebuyer or seller can make. In Ohio, a state with deep Catholic roots and a robust housing market, there are 105 Catholic real estate agents and brokers listed in the Discover Catholic Business directory, with 74 meeting our high-quality threshold. Whether you're buying your first home in Columbus, selling a property in Cincinnati, or relocating near a parish in Cleveland, this guide connects you with professionals who bring both market expertise and values-aligned service to every transaction.
What does it look like to work with a realtor who genuinely cares about your family's long-term wellbeing, not just the commission check? In Ohio's Catholic real estate community, that question has a practical answer.
Catholic Real Estate in Ohio by the Numbers
Ohio's real estate market is one of the most active in the Midwest, driven by affordable housing prices, strong job markets in Columbus and Cincinnati, and steady population growth in suburbs surrounding major metro areas.
| Metric | Count | |---|---| | Catholic real estate listings in Ohio | 105 | | High-quality listings (60+ quality score) | 74 | | Metro areas represented | Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, Dayton, and more | | Directory coverage | Statewide, all Ohio counties |
Ohio has approximately 2.1 million Catholics, representing roughly 18 percent of the state's population (USCCB, 2023). The dioceses of Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, and Toledo each maintain active Catholic business communities, and real estate is one of the sectors where faith-connected referrals are most common. Many of the agents listed here were first found through parish bulletin sponsorships and diocesan directories.
10 Catholic Real Estate Professionals in Ohio Worth Knowing
These agents and brokerages come from the verified Discover Catholic Business directory. They span the state geographically and serve a range of buyer and seller needs.
Myrna Gazzerro, Coldwell Banker (Beavercreek, OH)
Serving the Dayton metro area, Myrna Gazzerro operates through homesbymyrna.com and focuses on residential real estate in the southwest Ohio region. Beavercreek is a fast-growing suburb with strong school districts and a large Catholic population anchored by Wright-Patterson Air Force Base families.
CMG Home Loans (Cleveland, OH)
Cleveland-based CMG Home Loans offers mortgage lending alongside real estate support services. Their Ohio presence at cmghomeloans.com makes them a resource for buyers who want financing and guidance in a single relationship.
Sibcy Cline, Inc. (West Chester, OH)
One of the Cincinnati area's most recognized independent brokerages, Sibcy Cline has deep roots in the Greater Cincinnati Catholic community. The West Chester office, accessible at kathykramer.com, serves buyers and sellers across Warren and Butler counties.
Sibcy Cline Realtors (Harrison, OH)
A second Sibcy Cline presence in the western Cincinnati suburbs, this Harrison office serves the Indiana border region and surrounding communities. Contact via sibcycline.com.
Kopf, Hunter, Haas Realtors (Cincinnati, OH)
An independent Cincinnati brokerage at khhrealtors.com, Kopf, Hunter, Haas has served the Queen City market for decades. Their local expertise covers both historic neighborhoods and growing suburbs across Hamilton County.
New City Homes (Columbus, OH)
New City Homes is a locally owned real estate investment company focused on improving neighborhood quality through thoughtful development. Their newcityohio.com site describes their mission: recognizing and realizing development opportunities that provide superior housing and amenities for Columbus-area residents.
Tarter Realty / Shirley Ryan (Alliance, OH)
Serving the Alliance and Stark County area in northeast Ohio, Tarter Realty at tarterrealty.net positions itself as a digital resource for buyers and sellers in a region with strong Catholic communities connected to Canton and Massillon.
The Dorger Difference (Cincinnati, OH)
The Cincinnati-based team at dorgerdifference.com brings a personal, relationship-focused approach to residential real estate. The name signals what many clients find in faith-aligned real estate: a difference that goes beyond transaction.
Century 21 Realty / Chris DePiero (Parma, OH)
Parma, a suburb south of Cleveland, is one of Ohio's most historically Catholic communities with strong Polish and Italian Catholic heritage. Chris DePiero's Century 21 office at depiero.com serves this community with deep local knowledge.
Dzugan Real Estate (Crestline, OH)
Located in north-central Ohio, Dzugan Real Estate at dzuganra.com serves the Crestline and Crawford County region. Rural and small-town Ohio real estate requires different expertise than metro markets, and locally rooted agencies like this one bring that specialized knowledge.
More Ohio Catholic Realtors Worth Exploring
The directory also includes these professionals serving communities across the state:
- My Dog Sells Houses (Twinsburg, OH) at mydogsellshouses.com serves the northeastern Ohio market
- Donna Sanders, HomeSmart Real Estate (Chardon, OH) at homesmart.com covers Geauga County
- Ohio Real Estate Auctions (Upper Sandusky, OH) at paulventrealestate.com offers auction-style real estate services
- Huff Realty (Cincinnati, OH) at cincyarea.com covers the Greater Cincinnati area
- William Becker, Coldwell Banker Realty (Cincinnati, OH) at homesbywilliambecker.com
- Underwood and Associates, Better Homes USA (Calcutta, OH) at betterhomesusa.net
- Bruns Company (Tipp City, OH) at brunsrealty.com
- Howard Hanna Real Estate (Pepper Pike, OH) at tristonwinterich.howardhanna.com
How to Choose a Catholic Real Estate Agent in Ohio
Working with a faith-aligned agent isn't simply a matter of finding someone who attends Mass. The most valuable Catholic realtors combine professional excellence with the practical expression of values that matter to Catholic families. Here's what to look for:
Ask about their experience with your target area. Ohio's real estate markets vary dramatically. Cincinnati, Columbus, and Cleveland each have distinct neighborhoods, price dynamics, and buyer competition. A realtor with deep knowledge of your specific area, whether that's an urban neighborhood, a suburban township, or a rural county, will serve you better than a generalist working outside their expertise.
Verify licensing. All real estate agents in Ohio must be licensed through the Ohio Division of Real Estate and Professional Licensing. You can verify any agent's license status at the state's online portal before committing to a working relationship.
Look for transparent communication. The best real estate agents explain the process clearly, keep you informed throughout a transaction, and never pressure you toward decisions that serve their commission over your interests. This standard of service aligns naturally with Catholic principles around honesty and the dignity of every person you work with.
Ask for references from the Catholic community. Many Ohio Catholic realtors build their client base through parish connections and diocese-affiliated networks. Asking for references from other Catholic families can give you insight into how an agent performs when serving people who share your values.
Consider the full transaction team. Your realtor is just one professional in a home purchase or sale. Catholic-owned title companies, mortgage lenders, and home inspectors are also available through the Discover Catholic Business directory. Working with a team of faith-aligned professionals across the transaction creates consistency in the service ethic you experience.
Where to Find Catholic Real Estate Professionals in Ohio
The Ohio Catholic business directory includes real estate agents and brokers across all major markets and many smaller communities. You can also browse the real estate category directly to filter by location and find agents near your target area.
If you're relocating from another state, the full business directory covers Catholic professionals nationwide, so you can find support on both ends of your move. Ohio's 105 listed Catholic real estate professionals represent a starting point: the directory grows as more agents add or claim their listings.
For context on how Catholic businesses across Ohio compare to national trends, see our post on 37,000+ Catholic businesses nationwide, which covers data across all 50 states and major metro areas.
Working with a Catholic realtor in Ohio means more than a transaction. It means working with someone whose professional life is shaped by the same values that shape your family's. In a market as active as Ohio's, that alignment can make a meaningful difference in your experience from the first showing to the closing table.
Ready to connect with a Catholic real estate professional in Ohio? Browse the complete Ohio directory or search the real estate category to find agents serving your area.
Sources
- Discover Catholic Business directory data, May 2026
- United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, "Catholic Population by Diocese," 2023
- Ohio Division of Real Estate and Professional Licensing, ohio.gov